By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Natural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sectorNatural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sector
  • Food & Drink
    Food & DrinkShow More
    VOG has the organic apple for every need, 12 months a year
    February 7, 2023
    Almond Laboratories: 25 years being organic and plant-based
    February 7, 2023
    Even As Sales Cool for Vegan Meat, Veganuary Sets Another Record-Breaking Year
    February 6, 2023
    Spain will reflect its leadership position as an organic producer at Organic Food & Eco Living Iberia 2023
    February 6, 2023
    Folic acid in flour too low, say scientists
    February 3, 2023
  • Health
    HealthShow More
    Meet OQO at Natural & Organic Products 2023
    February 6, 2023
    Folic acid in flour too low, say scientists
    February 3, 2023
    Natural Products News’ News in brief
    February 2, 2023
    Government is ‘taking the biscuit’ says SA
    February 2, 2023
    Visit KeyPharm at BIOFACH 2023!
    January 31, 2023
  • Beauty
    BeautyShow More
    Meet Driu Beauty at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
    February 8, 2023
    Meet Selenacare at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
    February 8, 2023
    New Hair Proud collection champions diversity
    February 7, 2023
    Natural Products News’ News in brief
    February 2, 2023
    Natural and organic cosmetics outlook for 2023: What should I be ready for?
    February 2, 2023
  • Eco Living
    Eco LivingShow More
    Meet Clothes Doctor at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
    February 8, 2023
    Meet Selenacare at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
    February 8, 2023
    Natural Products News’ News in brief
    February 2, 2023
    Study Suggests Textile Reuse Up to 70x More Sustainable Than Producing New Clothing
    February 2, 2023
    CMA to investigate FMCG greenwashing
    January 30, 2023
  • World News
  • Distributors Wanted
  • Supplier Connections
Reading: Defiant Holland & Barrett tells ASA it has ‘no remit to rule on food claims’
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Latest News
Organic inputs, chemical-free production
February 8, 2023
Organics in international development cooperation
February 8, 2023
Meet Driu Beauty at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
February 8, 2023
Meet Clothes Doctor at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
February 8, 2023
Meet Selenacare at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
February 8, 2023
Aa
Natural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sectorNatural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sector
Aa
Search
  • Food & Drink
  • Health
  • Beauty
  • Eco Living
  • World News
  • Distributors Wanted
  • Supplier Connections
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Blog
  • Blog
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Natural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sector > Blog > Health and Nutrition > Supplements and Remedies > Defiant Holland & Barrett tells ASA it has ‘no remit to rule on food claims’
EuropeFeaturedSupplements and Remedies

Defiant Holland & Barrett tells ASA it has ‘no remit to rule on food claims’

Jim Manson
Jim Manson December 10, 2019
Updated 2019/12/10 at 11:35 AM
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

Leading health food retailer Holland & Barrett says the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), the UK’s advertising adjudicator, has “no remit to rule on food claims”. 

The retailer’s defiant stance was revealed this week as the ASA ruled that the company had breached the advertising code by using the term ‘weight management’ as a generic category heading on its website.

The ASA investigated the case after two complainants (one a former Trading Standards officer) challenged whether H&B’s use of the term ‘weight management’ was in compliance with EU regulations on heath and nutrition claims. 

In a submission of evidence Holland & Barrett said that all the products within the weight management category on its website could support claims that were either authorised on the EU Register as weight management/weight control claims, or were listed as ‘on hold’ botanicals claims awaiting authorisation. 

Legitimate claims 
The retailer also presented evidence on certain specific products. It said that its Nutritional Headquarters Fat Metaboliser product contained chromium “at a level that satisfied the requirements for use of the authorised health claim ‘chromium contributes to normal macronutrient metabolism’,” adding that “fat is generally accepted as a macronutrient by various authorities including the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA)” Other ingredients in the product – such as green tea extract and cayenne pepper – were among ingredients subject to legitimate ‘on hold’ claims, it said. 

But after consulting with both industry groups and non-industry experts, the ASA concluded that a statement about weight management, presented as a category heading, would be understood as a claim about the function of all the products contained within that category, and was itself “likely to influence a consumer’s decision to purchase those products”. The ASA also doubted that specific ‘on-hold’ claims cited in evidence by Holland & Barrett were likely to have the same meaning for consumers as the term wight management.

In relation to authorised claims for specific products cited by H&B, the regulator said that it “did not consider that the claim ‘weight management’ was likely to have the same meaning for consumers as the cited claims,” and that the company’s wording “went beyond the authorised claim”.

The regulator told the company that it must not use the categorisation ‘weight management’ to market food supplements unless all products under the category carry an authorised health claim.

No remit 
Perhaps the most striking aspect of H&B’s submission is its blunt rejection  of the ASA’s jurisdiction in this area. In its evidence the retailer said that the ASA “had no remit to rule on food claims in advertising generally without the advertiser’s agreement” and that the regulator was “not a control body for official controls on food under Regulation EC 882/2004”. 

The company added that even if the ASA were authorised to rule on food claims, the claims at issue were website category headings and not advertising under the CAP Code. 

In a press statement, Holland & Barrett, said: “As a responsible retailer, Holland & Barrett regularly reviews all product lines, and the categories in which these fall under, to ensure compliance with any legal requirements and to provide customers with clear and accurate guidance.

All of the products mentioned by the ASA in their ruling had compositions, which allowed relevant authorised claims to be made in respect of them in relation to fat metabolism or weight loss.

The term ‘Weight Management’ is a broad term encompassing a wide range of functions and is used as a category heading to help signpost customers. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has used the term to include, amongst other matters: fat metabolism; energy expenditure; metabolic rate; and healthy BMI maintenance and our primary Trading Standards authority stated that there was no evidence that the term ‘weight management’ is any way illegal.

Therefore, we believe that the presentation of our products under the ‘weight management’ category is not misleading to our customers.”

At the time of writing, the category heading ‘weight management’ continues to appear on the Holland & Barrett website. 

Dismayed
One of the organisations consulted by the ASA was the Health Food Manufacturers Association. Its executive director, Graham Keen, gave NPG his reaction to the ruling: “Our position remains the same, we believe category headings on websites are a helpful navigational tool for consumers, and not advertising. So when the ASA asked us to provide our views, we were pleased to have the opportunity to comment.

“Unfortunately, having provided thousands of words of feedback, primarily based on legal advice we sought, we were dismayed to find this was condensed down into just 68 words in the ASA’s published adjudication.

“In addition, we are very concerned that this ruling directly goes against the Assured Advice of H&B’s own primary Trading Standards authority, and that such Assured Advice must be respected by other enforcement bodies, but can be disregarded in this way by the ASA.”

You Might Also Like

Organic inputs, chemical-free production

Organics in international development cooperation

Meet Driu Beauty at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023

Meet Clothes Doctor at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023

Meet Selenacare at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023

TAGGED: ASA, Holland & Barrett, supplements, UK, website signposting, weight management

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Jim Manson December 10, 2019
Share this Article
Facebook TwitterEmail Print
Previous Article Publix opens another GreenWise Market store, targets 12 locations
Next Article Change incorporated: Mintel predicts brave new world of food and drink by 2030

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Organic inputs, chemical-free production
Agriculture Environment Europe February 8, 2023
Organics in international development cooperation
Africa Agriculture Environment Europe February 8, 2023
Meet Driu Beauty at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
Europe Natural Beauty NPG Partners Skincare February 8, 2023
Meet Clothes Doctor at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023
Eco Living Eco-Household Europe NPG Partners Textiles February 8, 2023
https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/922852467343286272/nzY8awcO_normal.jpg
@NPGalerts
887 Following
683 Followers
https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/922852467343286272/nzY8awcO_normal.jpg 6 hours ago
SolvPro, the new line of vegan plant protein blends from Osage Foods, is made using EverPro — the upcycled grain fr… https://t.co/YTVbv4ja7c
https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/922852467343286272/nzY8awcO_normal.jpg 21 hours ago
Organic Food & Eco Living Iberia and Bio Eco Actual present the Eco & Organic RETAIL Awards, with which the work of… https://t.co/I0rH46LTR6
https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/922852467343286272/nzY8awcO_normal.jpg Feb 7, 2023
FDA stands firm on CBD stance, stating that new regulations are needed. (Source: New Hope Network). Find out more:… https://t.co/15cvlZjYWk
1

Advertise

  • Advertise with us
  • Advertise with us
  • Newsletters
  • Newsletters
  • Deal
  • Deal
  • Distributors Wanted

You Might also Like

AgricultureEnvironmentEurope

Organic inputs, chemical-free production

February 8, 2023
AfricaAgricultureEnvironmentEurope

Organics in international development cooperation

February 8, 2023
EuropeNatural BeautyNPG PartnersSkincare

Meet Driu Beauty at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023

February 8, 2023
Eco LivingEco-HouseholdEuropeNPG PartnersTextiles

Meet Clothes Doctor at Natural & Organic Products Europe 2023

February 8, 2023
//

Natural Products Global is a one-stop global news resource for natural & organic industry professionals.

Natural Products Global is a one-stop global news resource for natural and organic industry professionals. Offering a mix of original content and aggregated news from leading industry websites.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Natural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sectorNatural Products Global | Delivering the news in your Natural & Organic sector
Follow US

© 2022 Natural Products Global NPG | All Rights Reserved

Sign Up!

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and get the latest natural & organic industry news delivered to your inbox

Name(Required)
Password(Required)
Strength indicator
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?